Inside Emmett Till’s troubled 67-year film history

The mention of “Twilight Zone” and the image of the host and creator of Rod Serling almost automatically comes to mind. The blockbuster anthology series that ran from 1959 to 1964 established Serling as a visionary who wove social commentary and an insightful understanding of human weaknesses in his fantasy, science fiction and horror stories.

Before the breakthrough, Serling tried, but unsuccessfully, to deal with the current problems even more directly: while working on another anthology, ABC’s Hour of Steel, he wrote “Noon on Extermination Day,” based on the brutal 1955. the murder of Emmett Till in Jim Crow South.

However, after handing over the initial script, Serling was ordered to change the race of the black and white characters to suggest an “unnamed foreigner” and move the scenery from the south to New England.

Serling protested as demands from censors, directors and sponsors continued: “It has become a summer … castrated kind of show,” he told TV journalist Mike Wallace in 1959, “who had nothing to do with what we allegedly said at the beginning. “.

His frustration helped ignite the inspiration to create “Twilight Zone” as your own vehicle. But the experience also illustrates the entertainment industry’s long-standing discomfort with the incidents surrounding the death of 14-year-old Till, who was kidnapped and killed after being accused of whistling a white woman at a grocery store while visiting relatives in Mississippi.

Till’s mother, Mamie Till-Mobley, made a constant battle to punish her son’s killers. Authorized Jet magazine to publish photos of her son’s mutilated body. Thousands attended his funeral in Chicago, where he was seen in an open coffin.

She also pressed for the development of a fictional film that would dramatize the fatal encounter. “The greatest thing Mother Mobley ever wanted was to bring Emmett’s story to the big screen,” said Keith Beauchamp, director of the documentary “The Untold Story of Emmett Louis Till.” “She said, ‘Keith, you have to keep telling Emmett’s story until the consciousness of man is raised, because only then will there be justice for him.”

Although Till’s death and his mother’s mission were key catalysts in the civil rights movement that gained momentum in the 1950s and 1960s, Till-Mobley’s and others’ attempts to develop homicide projects faced blockades for nearly seven decades. Hollywood favored civil rights projects involving the Reverend Martin Luther King Jr. and movies like “Mississippi Burning” from 1988, in which the dominant characters were white.

Till-Mobley, who died in 2003, did not live long enough to make her dreams come true this year, which featured two major Till-related projects: the feature film “Till”, released nationwide Fridayand the limited ABC series “Women of the Movement”, which premiered in January.

But despite the critical acclaim that welcomed both projects, their unveiling also highlights the lingering challenges faced by those telling Till’s story. In particular, the brutality of the murder of the young man – he was tortured and lynched – and the fact that the three killers were acquitted in a jury trial make it difficult to look at a true account of the crime.

Perhaps as a result, the makers of Till and Women of the Movement decided to highlight the loving bond between Till-Mobley and her son and the way Till-Mobley overcame her overwhelming grief with unwavering courage.

“I hope people will go to this movie and see each other in a mother-son relationship, see themselves in a mother-mother relationship,” said Whoopi Goldberg, who plays Till-Mobley’s mother, Alma Carthan, on Till.

Two black women in the lounge in the 1950s.

Danielle Deadwyler as Mamie Till-Mobley is gone and Whoopi Goldberg as her mother, Alma Carthan, in “Till.”

(Lynsey Weatherspoon / Orion Pictures)

Goldberg, who also executive produced the film, added: “I also hope people recognize themselves enough to say it’s still happening, and if we’re not careful, this systemic racism will spread to LGBTQ people, trans people, Asians. . and Native Americans. This is a global problem. Systemic racism starts out as one thing and progresses into something else. We see history erased, our history.

Goldberg bristled when asked about the decades of travel to bring Till’s story to the big screen: “I don’t understand why it took 67 years. This is the story of Anne Frank. This is a really hard story to tell. But they did manage to make this film several times. “

George Floyd’s murder in 2020, national outrage over the law enforcement killings of unarmed blacks, and the boom of the Black Lives Matter movement likely paved the way for two Till-themed projects in the same calendar year after the topic was ignored by so long by Hollywood.

“It is no coincidence that we are watching these post-George Floyd movies when the industry has been forced to confront all these nasty truths about American society, not just in the past but in the present,” he said. Darnell Hunt, Vice Chancellor and Chancellor of UCLA.

Beauchamp, who produces Till and co-writer the script, said: “There is no other story that would speak to this generation and this time of political and racial settlements. [like] the story of Emmett Till.

But luring viewers into such a painful story has been one of the main struggles over the years to bring what happened to Till to the screens. After enthusiastic reviews, the focus was on Danielle Deadwyler’s dominant role as Till-Mobley, “Till” He raised $ 3.6 million over the Halloween weekend, competing against escapist tariffs such as the DC Studios superhero movie Black Adam, Julia Roberts-George Clooney’s romantic comedy Ticket to Paradise, and the horror films Halloween Ends and Smile. The producers hope that the hype of awards for Deadwyler has the potential to increase the box office in the long run.

For its part, “Women of the Movement” received modest ratings despite being heavily promoted by ABC and a heavy roster of executive producers including Shawn “Jay-Z” Carter, Will Smith and director Gina Prince-Bythewood (“The King Woman”). The series was also disregarded by the Television Academy in this year’s Emmy nominations.

The financial prospects of such projects are further complicated by the national climate, in which discourse about race is becoming increasingly fierce and divisive.

A woman in black is crying by an open coffin.

A Public Wake Up Coffin for Emmett Till, as featured in the ABC Limited Series “Women of the Movement.”

(James Van Evers / ABC)

“We are at this incredibly polarized moment where much of the country is openly and actively embracing rather racist ideas,” said Hunt, who co-authored UCLA’s Hollywood Diversity Report, which studies diversity trends in the entertainment industry every year. .

Even black viewers can be reluctant To relive a heartbreaking story, especially after portraying racist violence on HBO’s “Watchmen” and “Lovecraft Country”, Amazon’s “Them: Covenant” and the Oscar-winning short “Two Distant Strangers” provoked criticism from Hollywood for profiting from “Black Trauma Porn” .

“At this point, there is certainly empathy for Emmett Till, who emerged in the aftermath of George Floyd’s murder, and a huge global response to this murder in sight,” said Lanita Jacobs, professor of American Studies and Ethnicity and Anthropology at USC. “But it’s hard and difficult. Black trauma porn, black death porn can be overwhelming. Here is a much needed spectacle of black death in the eyes of this mother. This can take a psychological toll.

But she added: “While there is some pain involved in bearing witness, there is also a responsibility on our part to bear witness. These people are no longer here. We have to respect them, say their names, create streets for them, create films for them. We need to talk about these things because in many ways they never really got what they were owed. This fact can lead to the withholding of justice. “

In this context, “Till” is much more than a movie, says Beauchamp. “This is movement. It’s an extension of what we’ve been doing all the time to fight for justice. “

And while this fight has led to tributes such as the Emmett Till Unsolved Civil Rights Crime Act, the Emmett Till Anti-Lynching Act, and statues paying tribute to Till and his mother, justice has still not been met, he said.

“This puts the cart in front of the horse because there is one person who can still be held responsible for the crime,” Beauchamp said, referring to Carolyn Bryant, the white woman whose accusation led to Till’s death. A Mississippi grand jury in August refused to charge Bryant with the murder and kidnapping, saying there was insufficient evidence.

Beauchamp said he hoped Till would reopen the case and convict Bryant.

“We must not lose sight of it,” said Beauchamp. The story of “Till” is not only the story of Emmett Till. This is America’s history. We put a mirror in front of everyone to reconcile the past. If we turn a blind eye to the past, it will sneak up on us again. “


Add a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *